Programmes with limited evidence

EAL reading

Educator's summary

As a PDF document

As web pages:
- Top-rated programmes
- Programmes with limited evidence
- Other programmes
- Review methods

Full report

As a PDF document (27 pages)

Limited Evidence of Effectiveness (Beginning Reading)

At least one qualifying study with median ES=+0.10 or more.

Reading Recovery
One-to-one tutoring programme for struggling pupils aged 6/7. Available in English or Spanish.
Available in UK Yes
Contact/ Website UK website: www.ioe.ac.uk
Direct Instruction-English
Structured, phonetic programme in English for pupils aged 5-12.
Available in UK No
Contact/ Website US website: www.nifdi.org US contact: kengel@nifdi.org
Libros-Spanish
Home and school reading intervention in Spanish for children aged 5/6 emphasizing books sent home to be read to children by parents.
Available in UK No
Contact/ Website US contact: Claude Goldenberg, cgolden@csulb.edu

Limited Evidence of Effectiveness (Upper Primary Reading)

At least one qualifying study with median ES=+0.10 or more.

Bilingual Cooperative Integrated Reading and Composition (BCIRC)- Spanish-English transition
Co-operative learning, oral, reading, and writing programme designed to help children aged 7-11 progress to English instruction.
Available in UK Yes
Contact/ Website UK website: www.successforall.org.uk
Success for All Transition
Adaptation of Success for All (see above) to help children aged 7-11 move to English instruction.
Available in UK Yes
Contact/ Website UK website: www.successforall.org.uk
Opportunities Through Language Arts (OLA)-Saunders & Goldenberg
Programme emphasizing literature study, writing, skill building and independent reading to help children aged 7-11 move to English instruction.
Available in UK No
Contact/ Website Bill.Saunders@PearsonAchievement.com
Vocabulary intervention-Carlo et al.
Vocabulary teaching programme to help Spanish-speaking pupils aged 9-11 improve their English vocabulary.
Available in UK No
Contact/ Website US contact: Maria Carlo, carlo@miami.edu